Base rate fallacy

Base rate fallacy

The base rate fallacy, also known as the base rate error, is a concept from statistics and probability theory that often plays an important role in decision-making and the judgement process. This phenomenon describes the tendency of people to neglect the base rate or background probability when assessing the probability of an event and instead focus on specific information or characteristics.

To better understand this concept, let's consider an example: Suppose there is a disease that is known to affect 1 in 1,000 people. A diagnostic test for this disease is available, and the test is accurate to 95% for both positive and negative results. Now the question arises: if someone tests positive for the test, how likely is it that this person actually has the disease?

This is where the base rate fallacy kicks in. Many people tend to intuitively think that since the test is so accurate, the probability of having the disease is close to 95%. However, this is a misconception. The actual probability depends on the base rate, in this case 1 in 1,000. If we apply Bayes' rule, it turns out that the probability of actually having the disease if the test is positive is much lower, around 2%.

This phenomenon is crucial as it shows how our decision-making processes can be influenced by false assumptions. People tend to rely on new information without adequately considering the base rate. This can lead to misjudgements, especially in areas such as medicine, finance and risk assessment.

To avoid the base rate fallacy, it is important to consider both the specific information and the base rate when making decisions. This often requires a conscious effort, as our brains tend to focus on tangible details. Statistical training and a better understanding of probability can help to avoid this thinking trap and make informed decisions.

In today's world where data and information are ubiquitous, base rate fallacy is a concept that is highly relevant in both personal and professional decision making. It emphasises the need for critical thinking and sound statistics to avoid bias and error.

To the glossary